If you had to give an answer, what would you say was the cause of your SEO failing? The truth is, failings don’t usually come from poor execution. A poor SEO campaign will have had its death warrant signed well before the execution stage.
It’s in the planning, or rather lack thereof. And once bad decisions get locked in, that’s it, you’ve sealed the fate, and the only way is down.
But it doesn’t need to be that way; you can change direction and get going in the right way. Let’s take a glance at a few SEO planning issues that will cost you time and budget, so you can avoid them.
Unclear Commercial Objectives
One of the most expensive SEO planning mistakes you can make is treating traffic as an objective instead of a proxy. If you’re not tying your SEO goals to revenue, lead quality, or pipeline contribution, prioritisation breaks down fast.
And you can expect to see it in some predictable ways when it shows up, too. It’ll look like keyword research that’s skewed towards high-volume terms with weak intent, and calendars that are full of “top of funnel” topics simply because they’re easier to justify.
But this isn’t productive or a good use of your budget; you won’t get the results you need. Instead, you need to have a clear commercial objective, such as:
- Generate qualified leads from organic search
- Reduce cost per acquisition by replacing paid traffic with organic
- Drive demo, quote, or enquiry requests for high-intent searches
- Capture competitor-comparison and solution-ready searches
Doing this will help you determine which search queries matter, what pages deserve investment, and what metrics are irrelevant. Without this clarity, SEO becomes a volume game that looks productive but doesn’t really do anything.
Treating SEO as a One-Off Task
SEO is not a one-time and done kind of deal, and pushing SEO as a finite project is simply setting yourself up for failure. While things like a new site launch, technical clean-up, or content push may bring short-term gains, they’re not what you should be resting your laurels on.
What you will experience is a gradual erosion of results. To avoid this, you need to build in resource planning prior to campaigns going live. You need to know how SEO work will continue after the initial launch, what pages need updating, and how to find new opportunities.
From here, you need to focus on things like content updates, regular technical reviews, periodic keyword and intent reassessment, and competitor monitoring. If you don’t feel this is something you can do effectively, or it’s outside of your capability, SEO is an excellent marketing activity to outsource to an expert SEO agency that can work with you to deliver ongoing results and put the right actions in place for long-term success.
Expecting Immediate Returns
Unrealistic timelines are one of the fastest ways for you to waste an SEO budget. If you’re expecting results immediately, not only are you in for a big disappointment, but you will also see confidence in your actions drop prematurely.
The pattern starts like this: investment begins, stalls, restarts months later, then starts again. Each stop resets momentum, learning is lost, and costs increase with every restart.
You need to step back and look at the bigger picture, you’re not supposed to get immediate returns for your SEO campaign, this is the long game.
For SEO you need to build milestones early that reflect reality: early validation milestones (indexing, impressions, crawl behaviour), mid-term indicators, and long-term outcomes. You need this for no-stop periods where work continues regardless of short-term movement and decision reviews at predefined intervals, not just reactionary check-ins.
By limiting expectations and grounding them in realistic time frames, you can avoid falling into the trap of thinking things aren’t working when all they need is time to materialise properly.
Inadequate Measurements and Baselines
A common thread in poor SEO campaigns is that they don’t begin with a defined baseline or success framework. And honestly, that’s not a strong position to be in.
From here, performance ends up being judged relative to recent fluctuations instead of a known starting point tied to objectives.
From here, it’s a snowball of misinterpretation: seasonal changes are mistaken for improvements, short-term volatility triggers unnecessary pivots, and SEO is judged unfairly compared to other channels.
Planning measurements upfront looks like a clear performance baseline for each priority page or section. It’s knowing which metrics indicate progress and which don’t, knowing what success means at page level, not just sitewide, and having a time window over which performance will be reviewed.
Baselines need to include:
- Rankings for target queries at the start point
- Organic traffic and conversions per priority page
- Existing click-through rates
- Seasonal context where necessary
No Ownership or Accountability
When responsibility isn’t distributed and ownership isn’t claimed, SEO planning breaks down almost immediately.
It might be that marketing controls content while development controls implementation and external suppliers control recommendations, but no one actually controls outcomes.
You’ll see it in delays first. Fixes sit in backlogs, content updates slip, and priorities change without reassessment. And while individually they don’t seem like anything major, collectively they erode performance.
The fix is easy: you need to assign ownership at the planning stage. One decision-maker sets priorities, understands trade-offs, and ensures execution happens. The role can be supported by specialists, but one person needs to be at the helm to make the required decisions. All decisions, from defined deliverables to how conflicts are resolved, which recommendations get worked on and what gets deferred, all need to go through one person so there’s a clear chain of command, and you know who has ownership over everything.
SEO planning determines the trajectory of your actions past this point. If you’re not putting the work in here, nothing is going to deliver how you need it to and your SEO efforts will fail. Even with the best content and keyword research, without these controls, nothing will go the right way.
Add Comment